Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Stories & Confessions ·

A neighborhood child has been grading the books in our sidewalk library

Stories & Confessions category photographStories & Confessions

Someone began placing letter grades inside books from our sidewalk library.

Charlotte’s Web received an A. A long gardening manual received a C-minus with the note, “Too many leaves, not enough plot.”

Borrowers loved the reviews. People returned books with their own grades, and the little library became busier than ever.

I assumed an adult with a dry sense of humor was responsible.

The reviewer is my nine-year-old neighbor, Eli. He has been reading on our porch after school because his apartment is crowded and quiet space is hard to find.

Last week, an author who lives nearby found her novel graded D and posted an angry photograph. Commenters mocked the handwriting before anyone knew a child wrote it.

Eli is crushed and wants every card removed. Other borrowers say the reviews are the best part of the library.

I encouraged the mystery because it attracted attention. I never considered what would happen when a real writer felt publicly judged.

Can the grading tradition continue in a way that protects the child and gives authors a little dignity too?

Discussion

5 community replies

Remove the post if you control it and reassure Eli that adults should not have mocked an anonymous reviewer’s handwriting.

Switch from grades to cards like “I liked…” and “I wondered…” or let readers recommend books without scoring them.

Do not reveal Eli’s identity to make the author feel better. He did not agree to become the public face of the library’s reviews.

The author is allowed to dislike a D. She could also choose to respond playfully to a reader rather than mobilize followers against a note card.

Which beloved book would receive a surprisingly low grade from your childhood self?

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Stories & Confessions

Explore more Stories & Confessions stories →