Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Stories & Confessions ·

A foul ball has been passed around our baseball section for four seasons

Stories & Confessions category photographStories & Confessions

A foul ball landed in Section 112 and bounced between six hands before an older man caught it.

He handed it to the nearest child.

The child watched two innings, then gave it to another kid before leaving. By the end of the game, five children had held the ball.

Our section turned that into a tradition. At every home game, one family brought the ball and passed it to a child for an inning. The ball collected signatures and nacho stains.

This season, a visiting family received it. Their daughter believed she had been given a real foul ball to keep. Her father took it home before anyone explained the tradition.

Regulars tracked him down through a photograph and asked for it back. He says adults should not hand a seven-year-old a baseball and later claim it was only a temporary loan.

He has a point. So do the families who carried it for four seasons.

Is the fair ending to let this child keep the original and begin a new section ball, or does the shared history justify asking for its return?

Discussion

5 community replies

I would let her keep it. The tradition was about giving children a moment with the ball; this time the adults failed to explain the handoff.

Invite her family to sign a new ball and mail it back as the start of the next chapter. That keeps them inside the story rather than making them the villains.

Do not keep identifying or contacting the father through crowd photographs after he has answered. A baseball tradition is not worth making a family feel pursued.

If the girl is happy to trade after understanding the story, wonderful—but the choice should not arrive wrapped in pressure from an entire section.

Would you value a ball more because you caught it or because hundreds of people had shared it?

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Stories & Confessions

Explore more Stories & Confessions stories →