Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

Would you take $20 an hour with fixed hours over $24 an hour with a variable schedule?

Money category photographMoney

'Don't take a pay cut,' my partner said when I compared two offers. In this illustration, one offers $24 an hour for between eight and twenty hours a week. The other offers $20 an hour and describes twenty weekly hours as guaranteed, on fixed days.

The first would mean $192 to $480 gross in those example weeks; the second would mean $400 for twenty hours. I still need to check the written hours, cancellation terms, deductions and other conditions. The higher-rate role also offers more choice about shifts, which would help with family commitments.

How would you weigh the hourly rate, usable flexibility and predictability? I don't want to call the first offer a regular $480 week or dismiss the second just because its hourly figure is lower.

Discussion

5 community replies

Use both the low and high example weeks for the variable offer. A maximum of $480 isn't the same budgeting information as an agreed twenty-hour schedule producing $400 gross.

Ask what each written offer actually commits to and how shifts are arranged or changed. Don't treat the word guaranteed or a verbal description of flexibility as the whole agreement.

Put the fixed days against your real family commitments. Flexibility has value if you would use it; predictable hours have value if they make the rest of the week easier to arrange.

Could saving part of the higher-paid weeks make the variable job the better choice?

It could help if those weeks occur often enough and you can retain the surplus. Test the lean weeks too, using reliable information about the offer rather than assuming the maximum is normal. Then decide what the flexibility is worth alongside the income uncertainty.

Join the discussion

More in Money