Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

Would you pay $1,000 in mortgage points to save $20 a month if you might move?

Money category photographMoney

In an illustrative comparison of the same mortgage, paying $1,000 cash in discount points at closing lowers the principal-and-interest payment by $20 a month. I don't know whether we'd keep the loan for three years or seven.

Dividing $1,000 by $20 gives fifty months. That's a simple payment comparison, not a complete calculation of loan balances, taxes and other costs.

The CFPB explains discount points as a trade between upfront cost and interest rate, and recommends comparing different possible holding periods.

What would you ask the lender to show before choosing? I like the smaller payment but don't want to buy years of savings we might never reach.

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask for a comparison at the three-year, seven-year and another realistic exit date, including the remaining loan balances and all relevant costs. Fifty months answers only the stated cash-payment calculation.

Check that both options use the same loan amount, term and other assumptions. A lower payment caused partly by a changed loan structure wouldn't be explained by the points alone.

Keep the $1,000 closing payment in the cash budget too. Future savings don't supply money needed for moving and other commitments at closing.

If you expect to stay seven years, isn't the answer straightforwardly to pay the points?

It may look attractive under that scenario, but your stated uncertainty includes three years. Compare the confirmed offers across those possibilities and decide how much upfront money you want tied to the longer outcome.

Join the discussion

More in Money