Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Food · Advice & Questions ·

Will my brownies bake the same way in a glass dish as in the recipe's metal pan?

Food category photographFood

The dish is the right width and length, so I thought I'd matched the recipe. Then I noticed it specifies a metal pan, while mine is oven-safe glass. Last time the edges became firm while I was still waiting for the centre to reach the recipe's doneness cues.

I haven't mixed today's batch. Should I find directions suited to this dish, borrow the metal pan or simply watch the brownies more closely? I don't want to raise the oven temperature because the middle seems slow if that would make the edge problem worse.

Discussion

5 community replies

Matching dimensions doesn't match heat transfer. King Arthur's comparison shows how glass heats and retains heat differently from metal, which can leave brownie edges further along while the centre catches up. Look for the recipe author's glass-pan directions instead of assuming the same time and setting.

Borrowing the specified pan would give you a simpler repeat before changing the batter too.

Check the glass dish's own use instructions as well as the recipe. 'Oven-safe' identifies a permitted use; it doesn't promise every metal-pan result.

If the brownies tasted good, could you accept firmer edges and treat that as your preferred version?

Only if you like that result and the batch is baked properly. The post describes an unwanted mismatch, so acceptance isn't the only reasonable answer. A suitable method for the pan gives you a better starting point than deliberately chasing hard edges.

Join the discussion

More in Food