Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

Why is heads not 'due' after five tails in our probability exercise?

Education category photographEducation

Our worksheet assumes a fair coin and independent tosses. In its example, the first five outcomes are tails. My partner says heads must now be more likely because the results need to balance out.

OpenStax's explanation of independence says that knowing one event occurred does not change the probability of an independent event.

I can repeat that sentence, but I still feel drawn to my partner's answer. How can I explain the next toss using the worksheet's assumptions, without confusing it with the probability of the whole sequence?

Discussion

5 community replies

Under those assumptions, the next toss still has probability one-half of heads. The five tails are already known; they do not change the rule for the independent sixth toss.

Draw the two possible branches after the five tails. The next outcome can be heads or tails, with one-half on each branch. You are continuing from the observed position, not choosing a fresh six-toss sequence before it begins.

A run that feels surprising does not create an obligation for the next outcome to compensate. That is the extra rule your partner's explanation has added to the worksheet.

Keep the assumed model separate from a question about a real coin. The exercise gives you fairness and independence; the five outcomes alone are not a demonstration that a physical coin satisfies those assumptions.

Exactly: explain what follows if the stated assumptions hold, and label any investigation of a real coin as a different task. Here you are explaining the worksheet's model; checking whether a particular coin fits it would be a separate investigation.

Join the discussion

More in Education