Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Food · Advice & Questions ·

Why does the chocolate-frosting recipe ask for hot water with the cocoa?

Food category photographFood

The frosting method starts by combining cocoa, some of the icing sugar and hot water. I was about to use cold water because I thought the only purpose was to make a paste. The hot-water step looked like an extra wait in a job I wanted to finish before decorating.

Before mixing, I checked the recipe author's explanation: the hot water also blooms the cocoa to develop the chocolate flavour. It isn't simply a choice between two equally wet mixtures.

Would you follow that sequence for the first attempt before deciding whether to simplify it? I want to understand which part of the method I'm changing, rather than assume an ingredient's temperature is incidental.

Discussion

5 community replies

Follow the method as written once. The author has explained a flavour reason for the hot-water step, so treating it as nothing more than dissolving the powder misses part of the intended job.

Get the decorating things ready while you follow the frosting sequence. Give any waiting time a useful job.

Don't carry this instruction over to every chocolate frosting. Other formulas may use cocoa differently. It explains this method, not a requirement to redesign one that already gives you a result you like.

If a faster frosting matters more than this particular version, could you choose a recipe whose whole method fits the time you have?

That makes sense before you start. Compare complete methods, including when they're ready to spread, instead of removing one step and expecting the original timing and texture to remain reliable.

Join the discussion

More in Food