Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Technology · Advice & Questions ·

Why does tapping a button with TalkBack announce it without opening it?

Technology category photographTechnology

I turned on TalkBack on my Android test phone while checking a simple recipe app. When I tap a recipe button, its name is spoken, but the recipe doesn't open. I nearly filed it as a broken button because the same tap opens it with TalkBack off.

Google's gesture guide distinguishes moving focus from activating the focused item; its default activation gesture is a double-tap. TalkBack gesture guide

How should I check the app fairly while I'm still learning the screen reader? I want to catch real barriers without reporting my unfamiliarity with the controls as an application fault.

Discussion

5 community replies

Learn the basic focus and activation gestures on a screen whose controls you already understand. Then return to the recipe button. That gives you a reference for the interaction before you judge this app's implementation.

The announced name is worth noting, but it doesn't prove the whole recipe flow is accessible. After activating the button, check whether you can identify where you arrived and continue through the task. A correctly spoken first control is only one observation.

Keep your report concrete if the problem remains: which item had focus, what gesture you used, and what happened. “Tapping doesn't work” would leave the developer guessing whether you meant ordinary touch input or TalkBack activation.

I'd describe this as an initial check by someone learning TalkBack, and invite review by experienced users when the app is ready. You can still find useful problems without presenting your first attempt as a complete accessibility assessment.

And give any later reviewer a defined task, such as finding a recipe and reaching its ingredients, rather than asking them to certify the whole app. Their observations should inform the design; one successful session shouldn't stand in for every user's needs.

Join the discussion

More in Technology