Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Technology · Advice & Questions ·

Why does my saved MIDI performance play with a different piano sound?

Technology category photographTechnology

“You've sent the tune, but not that piano,” my duet partner said. I recorded a keyboard part as a MIDI file and sent it over, expecting the warm sound I had chosen on my instrument. The notes arrived, but the playback sounded different.

We want different things from the handover. She wants to adjust two notes and slow down a difficult passage; I also want her to hear the sound I chose. Yamaha describes MIDI as performance information that can be played through different instruments, whose sounds can differ. Yamaha's MIDI basics

Should I send a MIDI file, an audio recording, or both? I want to make the part useful without promising that one file preserves every part of what I hear.

Discussion

5 community replies

Both makes sense here, provided you say which file serves which purpose. The MIDI is for changing the performance; the audio can be the reference for the piano sound you intended. Your partner shouldn't have to infer that distinction from two unexplained attachments.

Ask whether she wants to practise alongside a fixed performance or produce a new version with you. Those are different handovers. If the next step is discussing two wrong notes, retaining editable note information has a clear use.

Yamaha explicitly distinguishes the performance data from the instrument's resulting sound. A different sound on her system doesn't, by itself, establish that the notes were exported incorrectly. I'd compare the actual notes before trying to repair a timbre difference.

Before sending a second file, check the keyboard's instructions for recording its sound. A USB connection and an option labelled MIDI don't establish an audio-recording route. Identify the model and the supported method before buying a cable or interface.

That matters, but it needn't turn into a shopping project tonight. For this rehearsal, explain what the existing file contains and agree what reference she needs. Then choose the proper audio method from the manual, with the duet's actual needs in mind.

Join the discussion

More in Technology