Why does my saved MIDI performance play with a different piano sound?
Technology“You've sent the tune, but not that piano,” my duet partner said. I recorded a keyboard part as a MIDI file and sent it over, expecting the warm sound I had chosen on my instrument. The notes arrived, but the playback sounded different.
We want different things from the handover. She wants to adjust two notes and slow down a difficult passage; I also want her to hear the sound I chose. Yamaha describes MIDI as performance information that can be played through different instruments, whose sounds can differ. Yamaha's MIDI basics
Should I send a MIDI file, an audio recording, or both? I want to make the part useful without promising that one file preserves every part of what I hear.