Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

Why does dividing by a half give a bigger answer in our maths exercise?

Education category photographEducation

I changed 5 ÷ 1/2 into 5 ÷ 2 and got 2.5. The exercise asks how many half-metre pieces fit into an imaginary five-metre strip, so the answer key gives ten.

OpenStax models fraction division by counting groups of the divisor's size. I can count the pieces, but my old idea that division must make a number smaller keeps getting in the way.

How do I connect the picture to the calculation instead of remembering two conflicting rules?

Discussion

5 community replies

The question counts half-metre pieces, not metres. Each metre contains two of those pieces, so five metres contains ten. The strip has not grown; the units being counted are smaller.

Mark half-metre intervals from zero to five on a number line. Count the spaces between the marks, then label what each space represents.

Check the answer backwards: ten pieces multiplied by half a metre per piece gives five metres. Your 2.5 would answer a different question: half of five.

Be careful about replacing the old rule with 'dividing by a fraction makes it bigger'. Five divided by 5/2 is two, even though 5/2 is written as a fraction.

That comparison makes the useful distinction visible. For a positive starting number, dividing by a positive number below one increases it; dividing by one above one decreases it. The fraction bar alone does not decide.

Join the discussion

More in Education