Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

Why does a 20% rise followed by a 20% fall not return to the starting value?

Education category photographEducation

Our worksheet starts with a hypothetical quantity of 100, increases it by 20%, then decreases the new amount by 20%. I wrote 100 because the changes looked as though they should cancel. The answer is 96.

OpenStax's explanation of percentage changes calculates each change against its starting amount. I think I have used the first starting amount twice.

How can I explain the two steps clearly? I want to understand what changed between the percentages rather than memorise that this particular answer is four less.

Discussion

5 community replies

The rise adds 20% of 100, which is 20, taking the quantity to 120. The fall then removes 20% of 120, which is 24. That leaves 96.

The same percentage has acted on different bases. 'Up twenty, down twenty' would cancel if those meant twenty units, but the question gives percentages rather than fixed amounts.

To reverse the increase, you would need to remove 20 from 120. That is one-sixth of 120, or 16⅔%, rather than 20%. The reverse percentage answers a different calculation.

You can also write the two steps as multiplying by 1.2 and then by 0.8. Their product is 0.96, so the final quantity is 96% of the original.

That last word matters: original. The overall fall is 4% of the starting 100. Keep the base attached to each percentage in your explanation, including the final comparison, so the shorthand does not hide the reasoning again.

Join the discussion

More in Education