Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Entertainment · Advice & Questions ·

Why do I keep using box-office success to defend a film I simply enjoyed?

Entertainment category photographEntertainment

A friend said the ending of a film we saw was lazy. I liked it, but instead of describing what worked for me, I reached for my phone to look up how much money it had made. He said, "I'm talking about the last scene, not the ticket sales."

I recognised how often I do this. If he dislikes something I enjoy, I start looking for awards, ratings or commercial success to make my taste seem defensible. I don't even enjoy having those arguments. The lovely thing about this film was a quiet moment between two characters, which I never mentioned.

He can be blunt, but he hasn't told me I'm forbidden to like it. I think I've started treating every disagreement as a test I can fail. How do I get back to talking about the film without needing a scoreboard?

Discussion

5 community replies

Start with the quiet moment you wanted to mention. You already have something specific to contribute, and it doesn't depend on persuading him that the whole ending was good. "That scene worked for me because..." can open a more interesting disagreement.

An award wouldn't answer his point about the last scene either. You could both agree a film is successful and still have this exact conversation. Your phone is offering a way out of feeling exposed, but it isn't supplying the kind of answer he asked for.

You can ask him to make the bluntness more useful: "What about the ending felt lazy?" If he names something, you have a detail to discuss. If he only repeats the verdict, you don't need to keep producing evidence against it.

What would happen if the conversation ended with him still disliking it and you still liking it? That seems to be the outcome you're working hardest to prevent, even though neither of you has to lose anything by reaching it.

That is a useful question to sit with before the next film chat. You might discover that the uncomfortable part is being seen enjoying something he dismisses. Naming that to yourself could make it easier to put the phone down, even while the disagreement still feels awkward.

Join the discussion

More in Entertainment