Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

What should replace a school lift if the driver will only promise to open the windows while smoking?

Parenting category photographParenting

My dad has offered to collect our six-year-old from school once a week. It would save me leaving work early. When I asked for a smoke-free car, he said he would open all the windows while having a cigarette.

The arrangement has not started. I am grateful for the offer, but I do not want to agree to something on the basis that a window removes the concern. Dad thinks I am rejecting his help because I disapprove of him smoking.

The CDC advises keeping homes and cars smoke-free and explains that ventilation does not get rid of secondhand smoke.

How do I make the condition clear and deal with the transport gap if he will not accept it? My son is looking forward to Grandpa collecting him, and I do not want him given the job of persuading Dad or checking what happens in the car.

Discussion

5 community replies

Keep the condition specific: no smoking in the car. Opening the windows is not the alternative protection the CDC recommends. You can appreciate the lift offer while declining the version that includes smoking.

Work out the cost of saying no before treating the arrangement as settled. That may mean changing your work plan or asking about another collection option. None may be as convenient, but the inconvenience belongs in the adult planning conversation.

Tell your son that the adults are still arranging collection. Do not say Grandpa would collect him if only he cared enough to stop, or ask your son to report whether he smells smoke afterward.

Leave room for Dad to contribute in another suitable way if he declines this condition. The school lift does not have to become a verdict on the whole grandparent relationship.

Offer something concrete you can support, such as time together in a smoke-free setting, while keeping the transport decision clear. Do not keep the lift pencilled in on the assumption that affection for his grandson will change his answer at the last minute.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting