Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

What should I take to feedback when my main objection to the mark is how hard I worked?

Education category photographEducation

I read the mark, then opened the list of evenings I had spent on the report. It felt like evidence that the number must be wrong.

The tutor's comments refer to the assessment criteria. I haven't yet compared each comment with the submitted work. I know I spent a long time on presentation and checking details, and I want that effort to have meant something. I also know the rubric doesn't award a mark for hours spent.

My first draft of an email says I worked harder than several classmates. I can't know all the work they did, and that comparison wouldn't show which part of my report meets a higher descriptor.

What should I prepare for a useful feedback meeting? I want room to acknowledge the disappointment while finding out whether there is a specific marking concern or whether I need to change how I use my study time next time.

Discussion

5 community replies

Take the submitted report, rubric and comments, and identify the criterion you most want to understand. Ask how the evidence in the work led to that judgment. Your time log explains your disappointment, but it does not by itself identify an assessment error.

Look at where the hours went. You may have put substantial effort into a feature that carried little weight, or spent too long perfecting something before addressing a more important gap. Treat those as questions to explore with the tutor, not a verdict on your ability.

Leave classmates' supposed effort out of the request. You can make a strong case about your own work only if you connect it to the criteria. Guessing who worked less adds a comparison neither of you can properly assess in that meeting.

If you find a specific discrepancy, such as a criterion apparently overlooked or a total that does not add up, ask how the course checks it. Keep that request separate from asking for help improving the quality of the next report.

Bring the exact discrepancy and the relevant part of the work, rather than a general demand for more marks. If no such discrepancy emerges, the meeting can still be useful: ask what one change would make your next period of effort better directed.

Join the discussion

More in Education