What should I do when two tutors recommend opposite changes to the same report?
EducationOne tutor wrote, “Get to the evidence sooner.” Another wrote, “The reader needs more context.” I responded by cutting the opening, then putting it back longer.
Both comments concern the same college report. I haven't asked either tutor which material they mean by context or which part of the opening delays the argument. I may be treating two broad comments as opposite instructions before understanding the problem each reader noticed.
The revision is due next week. I don't want to ask who is right or follow whichever tutor I think will give the higher mark. I need a version I can explain through the assessment criteria.
What could I bring to a clarification meeting? I can show the original opening and a shorter attempt, but I would like to stop rewriting the whole report every time a comment seems to point in another direction.