Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

What should I do when two tutors recommend opposite changes to the same report?

Education category photographEducation

One tutor wrote, “Get to the evidence sooner.” Another wrote, “The reader needs more context.” I responded by cutting the opening, then putting it back longer.

Both comments concern the same college report. I haven't asked either tutor which material they mean by context or which part of the opening delays the argument. I may be treating two broad comments as opposite instructions before understanding the problem each reader noticed.

The revision is due next week. I don't want to ask who is right or follow whichever tutor I think will give the higher mark. I need a version I can explain through the assessment criteria.

What could I bring to a clarification meeting? I can show the original opening and a shorter attempt, but I would like to stop rewriting the whole report every time a comment seems to point in another direction.

Discussion

5 community replies

Put the two comments beside the exact passages they address. Ask what information the reader needs before the evidence and what can be removed or moved. The apparent contradiction may become more specific.

Keep both drafts rather than overwrite your way between them. You can use them to ask whether the shorter version loses necessary information or the longer one repeats material.

Ask how each suggestion connects to the criteria. A preference about pacing and a concern about missing context need not require one tutor to be declared wrong.

Bring a bounded question to the meeting: 'Which context does this claim need, and where should it sit?' That is easier to answer than asking someone to reconcile every comment on the report at once.

Try the resulting principle on a second section yourself. If it works there too, you have something more useful than permission for one opening paragraph. If it does not, bring the particular mismatch back rather than restart the whole report again.

Join the discussion

More in Education