Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

What should I do when my child remembers a promise I do not remember making?

Parenting category photographParenting

My nine-year-old put on her shoes after breakfast because she thought we were going to the craft shop. She says I promised we would go on Saturday. I remember talking about her model village, but not agreeing to the trip. I had planned to spend the morning finishing a repair at home.

I said, ‘I never promised that.’ She asked how I could be sure when I had just said I did not remember. There is no message or calendar entry to check. Neither of us can establish the exact words.

I do not want every uncertain conversation to become a commitment I must fulfil. I also cannot fairly turn my missing memory into proof that she invented an agreement. How would you handle today’s disappointment and decide what happens next, without making her produce written evidence for ordinary conversations with me?

Discussion

5 community replies

Change ‘I never promised’ to what you actually know: you do not remember agreeing. That does not settle the trip, but it stops treating her account as false simply because your memory is different.

Ask what she had understood about the timing and what she wanted to buy. You may learn enough to make a useful plan even if the original wording stays unresolved. The aim need not be to reconstruct a perfect transcript.

The repair at home can still matter. Explain what it prevents you doing today rather than using the memory dispute as the only reason to refuse. A workable alternative should be something you can offer, not a promise made to end the conversation.

I would avoid introducing a family rule that unwritten promises do not count. A quick shared calendar note could help with future trips, but it should not become a requirement a nine-year-old must meet before an adult takes her seriously.

Yes, and the parent can do the noting too. ‘Let’s put Saturday’s plan here so we both know’ is different from ‘You should have got it in writing.’ It supports the next arrangement without delivering a verdict on this one.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting