Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

What should I do when a paper on our reading list has a retraction notice?

Education category photographEducation

I opened the journal page to check a quotation and found a retraction notice above the article. The downloaded copy from the course site has no such notice on its first page.

The paper is on our seminar reading list, and I had planned to use it to support a claim in my essay. I haven't read the notice carefully enough to understand the reason or checked whether the tutor assigned the paper to discuss that issue. I don't want to assume the list is simply out of date.

Crossref's Crossmark service is designed to show publication-status changes such as corrections and retractions. It has reminded me that the copy I downloaded is not the whole record.

What should I establish before using the paper? I want to distinguish discussing the article and its retraction from citing its conclusions as ordinary supporting evidence, without guessing what the notice means or quietly ignoring it.

Discussion

5 community replies

Read the publisher's notice alongside the article and check exactly which record it concerns. A correction and a retraction are different status updates. Do not reduce the notice to a label without understanding what it actually says.

Tell the tutor what you found and ask how the paper is meant to be used in the seminar. It may be deliberately assigned as a case to examine. That would be a different purpose from the supporting role you had planned for it in the essay.

Mark the status in your research notes now, including the notice link. That makes it less likely that the unmarked downloaded copy slips back into a later draft as though you had never checked.

Review the particular claim in your essay that depends on the article. You might need other appropriate evidence, a narrower claim or an explicit discussion of the disputed work. Do not assume every other source in your paragraph independently establishes the same point.

Start with that one dependent sentence rather than deleting the whole section in panic. Check what the remaining sources actually support, then revise the sentence and its references together. If you discuss the retracted paper, make its status part of the discussion.

Join the discussion

More in Education