Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

What should I do before giving final approval as a student coauthor?

Education category photographEducation

The final manuscript arrived with a request to reply “approved” that afternoon. I am a student coauthor on a biomedical project. I helped prepare tables and reviewed an earlier draft, but the latest version has a changed conclusion that I have not yet understood.

The team is following ICMJE authorship guidance, which includes approval of the final version and accountability. A colleague says the senior authors have checked it and I should not hold up submission.

I want to keep contributing and do not assume the new conclusion is wrong. What should I ask for before responding? I am uncomfortable treating my name as a reward for earlier work while approving a version I have not properly reviewed.

Discussion

5 community replies

Say promptly that you have received the manuscript but have not approved it. Identify the changed conclusion and request time and the relevant explanation needed to review this version. A deadline does not turn acknowledgment of an email into informed approval.

Ask which analysis supports the change and which coauthor is responsible for that part. ICMJE distinguishes your own contribution from knowing who is responsible for other parts and having confidence in their integrity. You need clarification, not a claim that you personally repeated every analysis.

Being the student in the group can make this awkward, especially when everyone else seems ready. Keep the request specific and professional. Asking to understand an important revision is compatible with wanting the project to succeed.

If pressure to approve continues, use your institution's appropriate research-support or supervisory route for advice. ICMJE says unresolved authorship disputes belong with the relevant institutions. Do not start by assuming either that the paper is fraudulent or that your only option is to disappear from it.

That route can help you address the pressure without making an unsupported accusation. Preserve the distinction between declining approval now and abandoning your contribution. Tell the corresponding author exactly what remains unresolved, and seek institutional advice if the team will not allow a proper review.

Join the discussion

More in Education