Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Entertainment · Advice & Questions ·

What should I disclose after recognising a friend's story in a contest I'm judging?

Entertainment category photographEntertainment

The entries had numbers instead of names, but I recognised the first paragraph. I'd read an earlier draft of this story for a close friend last month.

I agreed to help judge a small writing club's contest before I knew she had entered. There are six entries and two judges. I haven't scored any yet. The organiser's email explains the scoring categories but says nothing about knowing an entrant or seeing a previous draft.

I think I could assess the finished story honestly. I also have information about its revisions that I don't have for the other entries, and my friend doesn't know I'm judging.

What should I tell the organiser privately before continuing? I don't want to reveal authors' identities to the other judge or quietly decide that being confident in my own fairness settles a situation the contest hasn't addressed.

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell the organiser you've recognised a close friend's entry and read an earlier draft. Those are two useful facts, even if you believe you can score it fairly.

Keep the disclosure limited to what the organiser needs. You don't have to send your old feedback or discuss whether the revisions improved the story.

Don't contact your friend to work out an arrangement between you. The organiser needs to settle how judging will work for all entrants before either of you starts negotiating exceptions.

Has the other judge already scored independently? Ask the organiser what options are available for replacing your assessment, rather than assuming dropping one score will preserve a comparable process.

And if a replacement is difficult, that difficulty belongs in the organiser's decision. It isn't a reason for you to hide the connection or invent a scoring fix on your own.

Join the discussion

More in Entertainment