Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

What should I check before putting pupils' essays into an AI feedback tool?

Education category photographEducation

I removed the names, then noticed that one pupil's first paragraph still identified the local event and family business she was writing about.

I teach in England and wanted to try an AI tool for drafting feedback on a few essays. I haven't uploaded them. The time-saving idea came from a colleague, but I haven't checked whether this tool and this use are approved by our school.

The Department for Education's data-protection guidance says to check acceptable use with the data protection officer or IT lead and discuss use of pupils' personal data before entering it. Removing a name is not enough for me to conclude that these essays contain no identifying information.

What should I bring to that discussion? I want to evaluate a possible teaching aid without making pupils' work the material for an experiment I have not properly cleared. I could begin with a teacher-written sample instead, subject to our approved process.

Discussion

5 community replies

Take the tool details, intended purpose and type of material to your school's data protection officer or IT lead before uploading pupil work. Describe the identifying detail you noticed rather than presenting the files as anonymous because names have been removed.

A teacher-written sample could let you explore the feedback task without using these essays, if the tool and use are approved. That would not by itself establish that later use of pupil material is acceptable.

Include what you would do with the output. Drafting comments for your review, making assessment decisions and sending automated feedback directly to pupils are different proposed workflows. The school needs to understand the actual one you intend.

Ask how you would judge whether the feedback is useful and accurate before it reaches a pupil. Saving time is only part of the question if checking unsuitable comments adds work or changes the message you intended to give.

Use a sample with a known teaching goal for that evaluation. Compare the proposed feedback with the work itself and your criteria, recording what would need correction. Keep that quality check alongside the approval and data questions rather than treat one as resolving the others.

Join the discussion

More in Education