Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Entertainment · Advice & Questions ·

What should I check before disputing a copyright claim on our choir video?

Entertainment category photographEntertainment

A choir friend told me to dispute the claim because I had filmed the performance myself. The video shows us singing a recent pop song with our own pianist. We aren't earning money from the channel.

The notice says Content ID claim. I haven't checked the claim details or what permissions our US community choir arranged for the upload. I had assumed making the recording ourselves settled the question.

I've now read YouTube's explanation of copyright myths and its dispute guidance. They don't treat recording something yourself or choosing not to monetise as enough on their own.

What information should I gather before responding? I'd like to help the choir share its performance, but I don't want to submit a rights claim simply because everyone agrees we worked hard on the singing.

Discussion

5 community replies

Start with the claimed content, the claimant and the action affecting the video. YouTube's claims guide explains checking those details; you need to know what you're responding to before deciding how.

Ask whoever organised the recording what permissions or agreements they actually have, including what they cover. Avoid turning 'we performed it ourselves' into a substitute for that information.

YouTube's dispute guidance says not monetising is not, by itself, a legitimate dispute reason. If the rights position remains unclear, seek qualified advice before asserting that the claim is invalid.

Check that the group understands the notice it received. A Content ID claim and a copyright strike are different, as YouTube's claims guide explains.

That distinction should help you read the actual notice, rather than dismiss it or assume the worst. The next decision still depends on the claim details and the rights you can establish.

Join the discussion

More in Entertainment