Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

What should I ask when essay feedback says 'more analysis' but I don't know what to change?

Education category photographEducation

The margin says “analysis?” beside the paragraph I spent longest writing. I can see the question mark. I can't yet see what a better paragraph would do.

The essay asks how a poem creates a sense of waiting. I described several images and a repeated phrase, then wrote that these create that feeling. The tutor says I have mostly described what is on the page. When I tried revising, I added words such as “powerful” and “effective,” which doesn't seem to answer the criticism.

I have a short feedback appointment next week. I don't want to arrive asking the tutor to rewrite the paragraph for me, or pretend that I understand an instruction I have only learned to repeat.

What could I bring and ask so the difference becomes concrete? I want to work on one part well enough to try the next paragraph myself, rather than decorate the same description with stronger adjectives.

Discussion

5 community replies

Bring the paragraph, the relevant lines of the poem and your attempted revision. Ask the tutor to identify one place where the paragraph needs to explain a connection you have only asserted. That is a smaller and more useful request than 'How do I analyse?'

What sort of waiting does your paragraph suggest, and which details make you read it that way? Trying to answer that could give you something to test with the tutor. You might discover that two images you listed are doing different things rather than all supporting one broad label.

Adding 'effective' gives a judgment, but your tutor may still be asking how you reached it. Do not assume analysis has to mean praising the poem more strongly. Your question about what the paragraph actually demonstrates is a good one to take into the meeting.

Ask whether the tutor can talk through a short example using a different passage, then let you attempt the same kind of explanation with yours. That would give you a model of the reasoning without supplying sentences for this assessed paragraph.

An example from another passage would leave you a useful test afterwards: can you explain your own choice of evidence without borrowing the model's interpretation? Take that attempt back if follow-up is available, or compare it with the feedback criteria before moving through the whole essay.

Join the discussion

More in Education