Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

What do I say when my child argues with every compliment about something he has made?

Parenting category photographParenting

My ten-year-old brought home a clay bowl with a blue inside and an uneven rim. I said it was perfect. He pointed to the rim and said it wasn't; he had wanted it round. I told him to stop arguing and just take a compliment.

He replied that I called everything perfect, so it didn't tell him anything. My partner thinks I was trying to cheer him up and that he could simply say thank you. I can see why having warm words rejected feels frustrating. I also described the exact part he was disappointed by as though there was nothing to discuss.

I do like the blue colour, and I'm happy he showed me the bowl. He hasn't asked me to fix it or arrange another class. He seems to want me to understand what he intended.

How can I respond warmly without arguing him into liking the result? I'd like him to receive kindness, but I don't want appreciation to require either of us to pretend we have the same opinion of the rim.

Discussion

5 community replies

Retire the word perfect for this conversation. He has given you a specific difference between his plan and the result. You can say, "You wanted a round rim and it came out uneven," without that being the final verdict on the whole bowl.

Offer the true compliment you actually have: you like the blue. You don't need to claim the bowl is flawless to appreciate it. A specific response also leaves him room to tell you how he chose or made that part.

Ask whether he wants you to look, listen to what went wrong, or help him think about another attempt. He may want one of those today and something else next time. Showing you a piece doesn't have to automatically trigger reassurance or a repair plan.

There can be two opinions on the table. You can like the bowl while he remains disappointed with it. He doesn't have to correct your liking, and you don't have to overturn his view of how closely it matches what he wanted.

That would let you say, "I like the colour, and I hear that the shape isn't what you planned," then leave some space. Repeating the compliment louder until he agrees would turn your enjoyment into another standard he has to satisfy.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting