What do I do when Grandpa admits smacking my child but says it is his way of disciplining?
ParentingMy six-year-old said Grandpa smacked his hand when he kept reaching for a biscuit. Dad confirmed it and said, “He needs to learn that no means no.” My son is with me now, and I have paused the next afternoon of unsupervised care.
I had told Dad we do not use physical punishment. He says he raised me this way and that I am making a family argument out of a small incident. My partner wants to explain the rule again and resume the arrangement because losing that childcare affects both our work schedules.
The American Academy of Pediatrics advises parents and caregivers not to hit or spank children and recommends non-physical discipline. I am not asking whether smacking is a useful compromise.
What would need to change before we could trust a care arrangement again? I want my son to hear that telling me was right, without giving him responsibility for deciding whether Grandpa gets another chance.