Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

What do I do when Grandpa admits smacking my child but says it is his way of disciplining?

Parenting category photographParenting

My six-year-old said Grandpa smacked his hand when he kept reaching for a biscuit. Dad confirmed it and said, “He needs to learn that no means no.” My son is with me now, and I have paused the next afternoon of unsupervised care.

I had told Dad we do not use physical punishment. He says he raised me this way and that I am making a family argument out of a small incident. My partner wants to explain the rule again and resume the arrangement because losing that childcare affects both our work schedules.

The American Academy of Pediatrics advises parents and caregivers not to hit or spank children and recommends non-physical discipline. I am not asking whether smacking is a useful compromise.

What would need to change before we could trust a care arrangement again? I want my son to hear that telling me was right, without giving him responsibility for deciding whether Grandpa gets another chance.

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell your son, “You were right to tell me. Reaching for a biscuit did not make hitting you acceptable. The adults are changing the arrangements.” Check how his hand is and get medical advice if he is injured or in pain. Do not make his willingness to return the test of whether everything is now fine.

Keep the pause while Dad is defending the smacking. Repeating the rule is not much protection if he believes he is entitled to disregard it. The AAP advice applies to caregivers as well as parents; being helpful with childcare does not settle this question.

Your partner's work concern is real, but it needs an adult solution. Look at temporary care, changed hours or other available help while you establish what can be safe. Do not send your son back solely because the alternative is inconvenient.

A future arrangement would need more than “I will try”: clear acceptance that physical punishment stops, a practical way to handle difficult moments and adults who can reasonably rely on that change. If you remain uncertain about protecting your child, seek advice from local child-protection or family-support professionals rather than testing it through another unsupervised afternoon.

That is a better question than asking your son to forgive him and resume care. Any contact also needs to take your son's feelings seriously without making him assess the risk. The adults must decide whether they can keep him safe and continue to act if Dad dismisses or repeats the behaviour.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting