Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

What could replace a blindfold exercise intended to show trainees what blindness feels like?

Education category photographEducation

The outline for our teacher-training workshop says we will wear blindfolds to understand how a blind pupil feels in class. The tutor wants us to think seriously about access, which I support. I am unsure that being suddenly unable to see, without preparation, can tell us what a pupil's everyday experience is like.

The National Federation of the Blind of Alaska's published guidance cautions against drawing that conclusion from pretending to be blind, pointing to the training and experience blind people may have.

How could I raise the concern and suggest an alternative that serves the learning aim? I would rather help improve the workshop than simply refuse the activity and leave that aim unaddressed.

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask what the tutor wants trainees to understand and what conclusions the exercise is meant to support. You can question the claim that it reproduces a pupil's experience while agreeing that learning about access belongs in the course.

Share the NFB of Alaska guidance as a published perspective from a blind-led organisation. Its concern is that an untrained person's short experience can give a misleading impression. Avoid presenting one source as evidence that every blind person holds the same view.

Suggest working through an actual teaching material or lesson plan using published guidance from blind educators or learners. The task could ask which information and activities are accessible, what needs checking and how a teacher would consult the pupil appropriately.

If the tutor considers inviting a blind contributor, ask that their role, preparation and terms be agreed rather than expecting someone to represent all blind pupils or provide a spontaneous personal account. Their contribution should have a clear place in the learning.

A guest should not have to become a substitute for planning the workshop. If an agreed contribution is not feasible, published blind-led resources could support a revised activity. The tutor can still ask trainees to examine assumptions and practical barriers without claiming they have experienced another person's life.

Join the discussion

More in Education