Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

What can my child say when friends treat a private question as a test of honesty?

Parenting category photographParenting

My eleven-year-old's friends have started asking who he has a crush on. When he says he doesn't want to answer, they say that means he must like someone and is hiding it. He asked me for a reply that wouldn't start another round of guessing.

I said he should just tell the truth. He pointed out that he hadn't said anything untrue; he'd declined the question. I hadn't meant that his friends were entitled to a name, but that was how my answer sounded.

He doesn't want to invent a crush or name someone to make the conversation stop. He also doesn't want to be teased for using a serious phrase like "that's private." I can't promise that any sentence will make the others lose interest.

How do I support a clear refusal while taking the social awkwardness seriously? I'd like to discuss honesty without teaching him that proving he has nothing to hide means answering every personal question.

Discussion

5 community replies

He already identified the distinction: declining to answer isn't the same act as giving a false answer. You can correct your advice without needing him to tell you whether there actually is a crush. The question is what he wants to share, not which name would make his answer credible.

Try wording that sounds like him. "I'm not doing crush questions" or "You can guess; I'm not joining in" might feel more usable than a formal announcement. Let him reject your suggested lines rather than insisting he deliver one exactly.

Ask whether this is an occasional annoying conversation or something that keeps following him after he's tried to leave it. If the pressure persists and he wants help, discuss who at school he could speak to. He doesn't need to produce a name before you take the pressure seriously.

I'd explicitly leave yourself out of the guessing game. "You can talk to me about this without telling me who you like." Otherwise asking for help with his friends' questions could turn into another version of the same questioning at home.

That also gives you a way to practise the reply without seeking a confession. You can play the friend asking, let him try a refusal and then stop when he says stop. The rehearsal shouldn't become an opportunity to test whether he really has something to reveal.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting