Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

We promised to match our child's savings. Does birthday money count?

Money category photographMoney

We told our child, 'Whatever you save for the bike, we'll match.' In my head, that meant the small amounts put aside from weekly pocket money. I didn't say that part aloud.

Using illustrative figures, there was $20 saved from pocket money, then $120 arrived in birthday gifts. Our child left all of it untouched and now expects us to match the full $140. We'd budgeted a $20 match. We could find the extra money by postponing a household purchase, but my partner wants to explain that birthday gifts weren't what we meant.

I can see why our child thinks keeping the birthday money counts as saving. I also don't want every future offer to become an open-ended promise. How would you handle this match and make the next offer clearer?

Discussion

5 community replies

Start by acknowledging the words you actually used. You pictured pocket money, but your child didn't hear that limit. Leaving the birthday gifts unspent fits a plausible reading of 'whatever you save,' even if it surprised you.

The extra $120 is a real change to the household plan. If matching it immediately would be difficult, say that plainly and discuss what you can manage. Acknowledging unclear wording doesn't require pretending the budget has no limits.

From the child's side, resisting the chance to spend birthday money may have felt like doing exactly what the offer encouraged. I'd be careful about describing gifts as a trick or a loophole. That could turn pride in saving into embarrassment about asking.

But the point was to reward effort. Why should money handed over at a birthday earn the same match as weeks of saving pocket money?

That could be a fair rule for a clearly explained future offer. This time, the promise was about saving, and the child kept both kinds of money for the bike. Explain the expectation you failed to state, then discuss the current shortfall without treating that unspoken rule as something the child broke.

Join the discussion

More in Money