Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Housing · Advice & Questions ·

We made an extra mortgage principal payment. Why has the monthly amount not gone down?

Housing category photographHousing

The statement shows that our extra payment reduced the mortgage balance, but the next required monthly payment is unchanged. My partner expected a smaller bill straight away. We had not asked for a payment recalculation before sending the money.

We have a current fixed-rate home mortgage in the US. We have not asked the servicer whether a recast is available for our loan or what conditions and costs would apply. I also want to distinguish the principal-and-interest payment from the other amounts collected with it.

[Fannie Mae's servicing guidance describes an agreed re-amortisation after a substantial principal payment as a way a servicer may reduce principal-and-interest payments under its rules](https://servicing-guide.fanniemae.com/svc/f-1-09/processing-mortgage-loan-payments-and-payoffs). That is a separate step to check, not a payment change we have already been offered.

What should we ask the servicer to explain before altering our monthly budget? I want to understand what the extra payment achieved and which options, if any, remain available on our actual loan.

Discussion

5 community replies

First ask for confirmation of how the extra funds were applied and the resulting principal balance. Keep the payment record and statement together. If those agree, you can discuss the payment schedule without confusing an application error with a separate request to change the required payment.

Ask whether your loan permits a recast, what rules apply, any minimum payment or fee, and when a new payment would become effective if approved. The Fannie Mae procedure is not proof that your servicer has agreed to a particular change. Get the proposal for this loan in writing.

Have the servicer break down the full monthly collection. A change to principal and interest needs to be distinguished from taxes, insurance or other items collected with the mortgage. Ask what each component would be under any proposed arrangement, rather than estimate the whole bill from the smaller balance.

Is recasting just another name for refinancing and getting a new interest rate?

In the Fannie Mae procedure described here, re-amortisation uses the current rate and remaining loan term to calculate principal and interest after the curtailment. Ask the servicer to distinguish that proposal from any refinance option. Do not assume a new rate, new term or lower required payment has already been approved.

Join the discussion

More in Housing