We have left an unlicensed HMO. Is it still worth asking about a rent repayment order?
HousingMy former housemates and I rented rooms in a shared house in England during summer 2026 and moved out in September. The council's licensing team has since written that the house required an HMO licence and did not have one during the period we lived there.
Our former landlord says we paid the agreed rent voluntarily, had somewhere to live and have now left, so there is nothing to discuss. One housemate wants to drop it. Another thinks the council's letter means we can demand every payment back immediately.
The government's current rent-repayment-order guidance includes licensing offences and says former tenants can apply, subject to the requirements. That sounds like a reason to get advice, but I do not know what our letter proves or what would be involved.
What should we gather and ask a housing adviser before deciding whether to pursue this, without treating a possible application as a guaranteed refund?