Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Weddings · Advice & Questions ·

We exchanged a duplicate wedding gift, and the giver wants a picture of us using it. How honest should our thanks be?

Weddings category photographWeddings

A friend gave us an espresso machine for our wedding, not knowing we already had one. We thanked her and used the gift receipt to exchange it for something else for our home. She has now asked for a photograph of our first coffee from it.

My husband suggests sending a picture of our original machine because it looks similar and would spare her feelings. I don't want to stage evidence that we kept the gift. I also don't want my explanation to sound like a review of why her choice wasn't good enough.

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell her the simple sequence: you already had a machine, appreciated her generosity, and exchanged the duplicate for something useful for your home. You don't need to catalogue what was wrong with the present when duplication was the issue.

A thank-you can be sincere without promising permanent use of the exact object. If your original message implied you were making coffee with it, acknowledge that wording rather than building a photograph around it.

She may feel disappointed, especially if she enjoyed choosing it. Let that be a possible reaction without rushing to prove she shouldn't mind or treating it as proof that honesty was a mistake.

I wouldn't use the older machine as a stand-in for the gift. The photograph would answer her specific question with a misleading impression, and you would still have the same explanation to give if she later asked about the machine.

Even an almost identical model wouldn't change what the picture was being used to suggest. You can offer a photograph of what her gift helped you obtain if she would enjoy that, without manufacturing a first-coffee moment.

Join the discussion

More in Weddings