Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

We disagree about whether a miniature-game ruin gives cover, and the battle has already started

Gaming category photographGaming

I moved a unit behind the ruin because I thought we were treating it as cover. My opponent thought that piece was decorative and says I would have positioned differently if we'd discussed it first. They are right that we didn't.

We are playing casually with homemade scenery. I don't want to invent a terrain interpretation that conveniently protects my move, and my opponent doesn't want to redo a whole turn because we left the scenery undefined.

How do we settle this position and make the rest of the battle clear? I want us to use the game's terrain rules deliberately rather than keep discovering what a piece means when someone benefits from it.

Discussion

5 community replies

Check the game's applicable terrain guidance together, then agree how this particular piece is being represented. Neither person's unspoken assumption should become the rule merely because a unit is already beside it.

If the missing agreement affected the move, discuss a limited repositioning before more information changes the situation. Treat it as a proposed repair both players accept, not an automatic entitlement.

Your opponent also had an assumption they didn't state. Acknowledging your part doesn't require making yourself solely responsible for a table neither of you defined.

Before continuing, identify the other scenery whose role could matter. A short agreement now is more useful than solving only the ruin and repeating the argument at the next building.

Keep that agreement about what the pieces represent, rather than who currently benefits. The same ruin should not acquire a different meaning when the other army reaches it.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming