Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Weddings · Advice & Questions ·

We disagree about shared platters or plated wedding meals. How do we compare the experience rather than the labels?

Weddings category photographWeddings

I like the idea of family-style platters at our reception because sharing food feels welcoming to me. My partner prefers a plated dinner. He imagines guests asking unfamiliar tablemates to pass things around a table already full of flowers and glasses.

I keep hearing “formal” when he says plated, and he keeps hearing “awkward” when I say shared. We haven't asked the caterer how either version would actually be served at our tables. What should we compare before choosing a whole atmosphere from those two words?

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask the caterer to walk you through each service with your actual table layout and menu. Where would the platters sit, who would serve, and what would staff do? You may be arguing about versions neither of you is being offered.

Your descriptions carry different memories of a good meal. Talk about those without making either person defend the entire style. Warmth can come from conversation and hospitality as well as how food reaches a plate.

Consider how guests who find passing or reaching inconvenient would receive their meal in the shared version. Ask about a workable arrangement rather than assuming a neighbour will take responsibility. That question doesn't require abandoning the style before you hear the options.

You might prefer a combination if the caterer can genuinely provide one. Get the service and price explained before treating “some of each” as an easy compromise; it could be a different arrangement rather than a halfway point.

And choose it because you like the experience described, not merely because neither of you had to give up entirely. A more complicated service isn't automatically a kinder compromise. Check that it preserves what each of you actually wanted.

Join the discussion

More in Weddings