Two readers want opposite changes to my story, and I keep trying to satisfy both
EntertainmentOne friend says my story would be more moving if readers knew from the first page that the narrator caused the accident. Another says that fact should be saved for the end because the mystery is what kept her reading.
I tried both changes, one after the other. Now the opening hints so heavily that the ending feels like an announcement of something already obvious. When the friends ask how the revision is going, I say their notes were helpful, which is true, but I haven't admitted that I used them as instructions I somehow had to combine.
I wanted a story about someone avoiding an admission. I need to decide what readers should know while that happens, rather than keep moving the confession until nobody could possibly object.