Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Entertainment · Advice & Questions ·

Two readers want opposite changes to my story, and I keep trying to satisfy both

Entertainment category photographEntertainment

One friend says my story would be more moving if readers knew from the first page that the narrator caused the accident. Another says that fact should be saved for the end because the mystery is what kept her reading.

I tried both changes, one after the other. Now the opening hints so heavily that the ending feels like an announcement of something already obvious. When the friends ask how the revision is going, I say their notes were helpful, which is true, but I haven't admitted that I used them as instructions I somehow had to combine.

I wanted a story about someone avoiding an admission. I need to decide what readers should know while that happens, rather than keep moving the confession until nobody could possibly object.

Discussion

5 community replies

Both notes describe a possible story. They don't have to be merged into one compromise. Return to the experience you want the reader to have while the narrator avoids the admission: waiting for honesty feels different from discovering guilt at the end.

Ask what each reader found moving or puzzling in the draft they actually read. Their reactions may be more useful than their preferred placement of the reveal. You can learn from both even if you follow neither proposed fix.

You don't need to tell them that their advice broke the story. You made the revisions. "I tried both approaches and realised I need to choose what the opening lets readers know" owns that experiment without pretending either friend gave a bad note.

Could you put the two versions aside briefly and read the draft for where the narrator's avoidance becomes interesting? That might reveal the part you keep protecting, instead of making the confession's position the only decision that matters.

That could help, especially if you stop treating another move of the reveal as a guaranteed repair. The useful next draft is one whose choices you can explain to yourself. It doesn't need to prevent those two friends from still preferring different versions.

Join the discussion

More in Entertainment