Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Housing · Advice & Questions ·

Two installers suggest different heat-pump sizes. Should we choose the larger one to be safe?

Housing category photographHousing

We have two proposals for a heat pump at our US home, with different capacities. My partner prefers the larger unit because the old system struggled on cold evenings. I asked how the capacities were chosen and received reassuring descriptions of the equipment, but no explanation we could follow about our home's needs.

We have added insulation since the old system was installed. I do not know how either proposal accounts for that, or whether the cold back room is being addressed by the proposed design.

The Department of Energy's sizing guidance starts with determining the home's heating and cooling loads and selecting equipment on that basis.

I do not want to choose the smaller system to save money and regret it. I also do not want 'larger' to stand in for an assessment. What should we ask each installer to explain so we can compare the proposals?

Discussion

5 community replies

Bring the cold back room into the discussion explicitly. Ask how each proposal will meet the needs of that room, including how the system will deliver heating and cooling there. Do not diagnose the old problem yourselves and assume that more total capacity is its remedy.

Your partner is trying to avoid another winter of being uncomfortable. Keep that goal in the comparison. Asking for the design basis is how you test whether a proposal meets it, rather than an argument that comfort matters less than the price.

How much of the technical calculation should a homeowner be expected to understand before signing? A report full of unexplained figures would not help much.

You should be able to ask what information was collected, which assumptions were used and why the proposed equipment fits the results. Have the installer explain the parts that affect your choice, including the back room and the changes you made to the home. If the explanation remains unclear, a second qualified assessment is more useful than trying to design the system yourselves.

Join the discussion

More in Housing