Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

Two friends broke up, and one wants me to remove the other from our campaign

Gaming category photographGaming

I run a fortnightly campaign for five friends. Two of them recently broke up, and one has asked me privately to stop inviting the other. They haven't reported any misconduct at the game; they say sitting together for an evening would be too uncomfortable.

Both had been part of the campaign from the start. I haven't promised either person a decision, and the rest of the group doesn't know about the request. I care about both friends, but I don't feel able to decide who deserves the group based on conversations about the breakup.

How do I work out what happens to the campaign without becoming the judge of their relationship? I understand that keeping the same invitations may mean someone chooses not to attend, but removing a player to avoid that would also be a decision about the whole group.

Discussion

5 community replies

Be clear about what you can discuss: whether each person wants to keep attending, what conduct is expected at the table and what arrangements are feasible. You don't need a verdict on the breakup to have that conversation.

The friend asking may genuinely be unable to enjoy an evening with their ex. You can acknowledge that without promising that the way to solve it is excluding the other player.

Don't announce a new arrangement to the group while one person still thinks their invitation is unchanged. Speak directly with the affected players before treating a possible plan as settled.

It may not be possible to keep this exact five-person campaign and make both people comfortable right now. That is a loss to acknowledge, rather than proof that you failed to find the perfect seating plan.

If someone steps back, discuss what that means for their character and future invitations instead of letting silence decide it. You can handle the campaign thoughtfully even when you can't restore the group it had before the breakup.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming