Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Health · Advice & Questions ·

Turning off ICD shocks sounds like turning off my heart. How do I understand what the team is actually proposing?

Health category photographHealth

During a conversation about my advanced illness, the team raised whether I would want my implanted defibrillator to keep delivering shocks near the end of life. I heard 'deactivate' and immediately thought they meant stopping every function of the device. I asked for another discussion before making a decision.

Cambridge University Hospitals explains that ICD shock treatment can be disabled while pacing continues. It also explains the consequence: a dangerous heart rhythm would no longer receive that shock treatment. I need those two facts together, not reassurance that leaves out what protection I would be giving up.

What would help me have a clearer conversation with the device and palliative-care teams about my particular device, my wishes and whether or when I want anything changed?

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask the device team to name the functions your own device provides and exactly which setting is being discussed. The CUH leaflet distinguishes stopping shocks from stopping pacing. The word 'off' on its own is too imprecise for the decision you are being asked to consider.

Both sides deserve a plain explanation: shocks may become distressing or inappropriate as illness advances, and disabling them removes their protection against a dangerous rhythm. Ask how the team thinks those benefits and burdens apply to you, rather than assuming the same choice fits everyone with an ICD.

You can discuss the option before deciding. Bring the questions you did not manage to ask the first time, and invite someone you trust if you want support. A conversation about future care should give you room to express what matters to you, including uncertainty.

Ask how the decision would be recorded, who would arrange any agreed change and whom to contact if you reconsidered. CUH says reactivation can be discussed with the treating team. This is a clinical service to coordinate; relatives should not try to alter the device themselves.

Include what happens if you change your mind after moving between home, hospital or hospice. Having the same documented decision available to the relevant teams may spare you another frightening explanation. You can ask them to read the plan back in terms you understand before it is finalised.

Join the discussion

More in Health