Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

The umbrella policy quote is $200 a year. What if the required auto-policy change costs another $120?

Money category photographMoney

'Two hundred dollars buys the extra protection,' my partner said. In this New York insurance illustration, the umbrella quote is $200 a year, but meeting its stated auto-liability requirements would add another $120 to our annual auto premium. I had put only $200 in the budget.

We haven't bound or changed coverage. The New York insurance department explains that umbrella insurers may require minimum underlying liability limits. The actual policies and their conditions need to fit together.

What would you ask the agent before deciding? I want to compare the complete arrangement and its exclusions, rather than either reject it because the first price was incomplete or assume the umbrella can sit above whatever auto cover we already have.

Discussion

5 community replies

Under the stated annual figures, the incremental premium is $320. Ask for a written breakdown of all required changes so the comparison uses the full cost.

Have the agent identify the required underlying policies, limits, insured people and effective dates. Check them against your actual declarations and the proposed umbrella terms.

Ask what the policy covers and excludes, and discuss the protection you are trying to obtain. A large headline limit doesn't establish that every situation or household member is included.

Could you keep the cheaper auto limits and rely on the umbrella to fill any difference?

Ask the insurer exactly how that situation is treated; don't assume the umbrella removes its own underlying-coverage requirements. Obtain a clear explanation of where each policy would respond and any amount left to you before choosing a cheaper base arrangement.

Join the discussion

More in Money