Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Housing · Advice & Questions ·

The seller has an old photo of the same crack. Does that answer the survey's concern?

Housing category photographHousing

A survey of a house we hope to buy in England flags a crack near a window and recommends further assessment. The seller has found an old photograph showing a crack in the same place and says this proves it is historic and harmless.

My partner finds the photograph reassuring. I think it is useful information, but I cannot tell from it whether the crack has changed or what caused it. The RICS consumer guide describes how investigating suspected movement may require professional assessment and monitoring.

We do not want to assume every crack means a serious structural problem. We also do not want a photograph to stand in for the assessment already recommended.

What should we ask the surveyor to establish with the photograph and any other available records before deciding how to proceed?

Discussion

5 community replies

Give the surveyor the photograph with its available date and ask what it does and does not establish. It may add history without answering the cause or whether movement is continuing. Have the professional explain why further assessment was recommended and what would resolve that concern.

Ask for any relevant reports, repairs, monitoring records or previous investigations through the buying team. Do not infer from an old image that there must have been a formal diagnosis, or that the absence of records proves the worst.

The seller has offered to fill and repaint it before completion. Would that at least show the issue has been put right?

A cosmetic finish would not by itself establish the cause or the adequacy of any necessary repair. Ask the surveyor what work, assessment and records would address the concern before agreeing that the offer resolves it. Do not let a tidier surface close an unanswered structural question.

Join the discussion

More in Housing