Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

The restaurant added a service charge. How do we decide whether to leave another tip?

Money category photographMoney

The bill has a compulsory service charge and still leaves a blank tip line. Using illustrative figures, dinner is $100 before an $18 service charge, with tax set aside for this example. My partner sees the charge as the server's tip already paid. I don't know what the restaurant does with it, so I'm uncomfortable making that assumption either way.

For U.S. federal wage-law purposes, the Department of Labor distinguishes a compulsory service charge from a tip. That classification doesn't tell us how this restaurant distributes its charge or settle every state or local rule.

Neither of us wants to put the server on the spot, and neither wants to add money simply because there's another line on the receipt. How would you ask what the charge covers and then agree on the total?

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask a straightforward question about the restaurant's policy: 'What does the service charge cover, and is it distributed to the staff serving this table?' The label alone hasn't answered what you and your partner are actually disagreeing about.

You can ask a manager or check the menu's explanation if discussing it directly with the server feels awkward. Keep the question about the restaurant's charge, rather than asking the server to justify the business's pricing.

Before adding anything, agree on the bill you're already paying. In the example, that's $118 before tax. Treat any voluntary addition as another spending decision once you understand the charge, rather than calculating from the empty tip line alone.

Wouldn't adding a tip mean tipping twice? If the restaurant chose an 18% charge, I can see why someone would feel they'd already dealt with that part of the bill.

That feeling is understandable, but 'twice' assumes you know what the charge represents and where it goes. Find out the restaurant's policy first. You can then choose whether to add a voluntary tip without assuming either that the full $18 went to the server or that none of it benefited staff.

Join the discussion

More in Money