Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Entertainment · Advice & Questions ·

The joke I brought to writing group turns out to be from a clip I saw

Entertainment category photographEntertainment

Our comedy-writing group laughed at a line I brought in, and I said I'd finally come up with a good ending for my set. On the bus home I remembered a video I'd watched months ago. I found it again, and there was almost the same joke, including the turn I was proudest of.

I hadn't deliberately copied it, but I can't honestly call it mine now. I haven't performed the set publicly. The group leader has asked everyone to bring their revised material next week, and I could simply replace the ending.

That would solve the upcoming performance, but several people complimented me specifically on that line. I'm embarrassed about telling them what happened after accepting the praise so happily.

Should I explain it to the group, and how much explanation is useful before it starts sounding like I'm making excuses?

Discussion

5 community replies

Replace the ending and make a short correction next time: “I realised that line was something I'd seen before, so I've taken it out.” You can correct the impression without delivering a speech about your intentions.

Keeping the rediscovered clip to yourself would leave the specific praise uncorrected. That seems to be the part bothering you, rather than whether you can quietly improve the next draft.

Don't try to rescue the joke by changing a few surface details. You're already able to identify the turn as someone else's; give yourself a different problem to write towards.

You can acknowledge that you accepted credit by mistake without claiming you knowingly stole it. Those are different accounts of what happened, and your explanation should stay accurate.

Exactly. “I thought I'd written it, then recognised the source” takes responsibility for the correction. It doesn't need either a defence brief or a harsher confession than the facts support.

Join the discussion

More in Entertainment