Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

The GM wants my character to betray the party. How do we check boundaries without revealing the twist?

Gaming category photographGaming

The GM privately suggested that my character steal the crew's map for a rival faction. I like the dramatic possibility, but the campaign was introduced as a story about a crew working together. I don't know how the other players feel about a player character secretly working against them.

I'd rather check that than discover it through everyone's reaction to the reveal. How can we discuss the possibility of conflict between characters without announcing who might betray whom? I also recognise that even a general conversation may make the others suspect a twist is coming.

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask the GM to clarify the table's understanding of character conflict before agreeing to the plan. Enjoying a secret in the story and enjoying a secret change to the kind of game are different things.

The conversation can cover actions such as stealing party resources, misleading other characters or fighting them, without naming the map or the rival faction. Let people describe what they would and wouldn't enjoy.

You can decline this particular twist while still giving the GM other ideas involving the faction. You don't have to accept a role that depends on an agreement the group hasn't established.

The boundaries conversation may reduce the surprise. That's a real creative cost, but preserving every bit of suspense isn't a good reason to leave the group's expectations unresolved.

Exactly. If the twist only works when the players don't know that this kind of character conflict is possible, consider a different twist. The story can keep secrets while the people playing still understand the broad arrangement.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming