Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

The fund paid me $60 but my shares fell by $40. Did I gain $60 or lose $40?

Money category photographMoney

I started the period with fund shares worth $1,000. They ended at $960, and I received a $60 cash distribution that stayed outside the fund. There were no new contributions or other withdrawals in this illustration.

My partner looked only at the share value and said I'd lost $40. I looked only at the cash and said I'd earned $60. Together, the remaining shares and cash total $1,020 before any taxes or separate charges.

The SEC's fund-distribution bulletin explains why a distribution isn't the same as fund performance, and why its source matters.

What would you compare on the statements to understand the whole result without turning the payout into proof that the investment performed well?

Discussion

5 community replies

On your stated assumptions, $960 plus $60 is $1,020: $20 above the starting value. Keep that simple reconciliation separate from any annualized performance figure or after-tax result you haven't calculated.

Check what the distribution consists of. The SEC bulletin explains that distributions may include investment income, gains or a return of capital. A cash payment alone doesn't identify its source.

Use the same period and treatment of distributions when comparing a reported fund return with your records. Otherwise the two figures may answer different questions.

If the $60 had been reinvested, could you still add it to the ending share value to see the total?

Check whether the ending value already includes the additional shares bought with it. If so, adding the same $60 again would count it twice. This example avoids that by stating the cash stayed outside the fund.

Join the discussion

More in Money