Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Career / Work · Advice & Questions ·

The farewell speech says he was my greatest mentor. He wasn't.

Career / Work category photographCareer / Work

A colleague is retiring, and I've been asked to give the short farewell speech because we worked together for six years. Someone has helpfully drafted it for me. It says he was my greatest mentor and that I owe my career to him.

He taught me some useful things and helped rescue a difficult event. He also made several of those six years harder than they needed to be. I don't want to use a farewell to settle that account, and I know other people had a warmer relationship with him.

The organiser thinks the draft is just normal leaving-speech language and says changing it will look pointed. I can name things I sincerely appreciate, but I don't want to stand up and describe a relationship I didn't have. Is a shorter, more factual speech enough, or should I hand the microphone to someone who means the bigger sentiments?

Discussion

5 community replies

A warm speech can be accurate. The rescued event gives you a real story to tell, and you can thank him for particular skills he passed on. There is no need to announce why you removed the grand claim. Give the organiser your finished replacement so they can judge its actual tone.

I'd ask whether someone with a closer relationship wants the main speech, with you contributing the event story. That could improve the occasion without making a public statement about your history. It doesn't have to be presented as a protest.

Avoid making the rewrite an inventory of measurable outputs. A small generous detail about how he approached that event might carry more feeling than a list of projects. You can be kind without assigning him credit for your entire career.

If everyone knows you worked together for six years, won't an unusually brief speech still communicate that something was wrong? I can see why the organiser is nervous.

Possibly, but length isn't the only signal. A complete little story, thanks and a good wish can feel deliberate rather than grudging. I'd rehearse the replacement with the organiser. If they still require words you don't mean, another speaker is a reasonable way to meet the occasion.

Join the discussion

More in Career / Work