Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Housing · Advice & Questions ·

The deposit-replacement fee is smaller. What would we still owe at the end of the tenancy?

Housing category photographHousing

The agent offered us a choice between a refundable tenancy deposit and a deposit-replacement product. My flatmate called the smaller initial payment a saving. The product summary describes a non-refundable joining fee and an annual charge, but we have not worked through what happens if the landlord makes a claim.

We are applying for a private rental in England. The traditional deposit would tie up more of our savings during the tenancy; the alternative would leave us more cash for moving. I can see the attraction without being sure we are comparing the same kind of payment.

[The government's tenant-fees guidance says tenants may choose a deposit-replacement product, but cannot be required to buy a loan, insurance or service contract as a condition of the tenancy](https://www.gov.uk/guidance/tenant-fees-act-2019-guidance-for-tenants).

What should we have explained before choosing? I want to understand the ongoing fees and any remaining liability, rather than assume that paying less at move-in means the whole arrangement costs less.

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask the provider to walk through an example of a disputed damage or rent claim: who decides it, who initially pays whom, what the tenant could be asked to repay and how a challenge works. Do not infer those terms from the product's name or the size of the joining fee.

Get a complete schedule of fees, renewal arrangements and cancellation terms. Then compare that with the traditional deposit option and what money might be returned under it. Cash that is temporarily unavailable and fees that are not returned affect your budget in different ways.

Keep the choice explicit. The current government guidance identifies deposit-replacement products as something a tenant can choose, not a compulsory service purchase. If the agent changes its account of the available options, ask for clarification in writing and get housing advice.

If the product is described as insurance, doesn't that mean the insurer pays for damage instead of us?

Ask who is insured and whether the provider can recover a payment from you. Those are contract questions; insurance in the description does not establish that your own liability has been removed. Have the relevant terms explained before treating the fee as protection against everything a landlord might claim.

Join the discussion

More in Housing