The deposit-replacement fee is smaller. What would we still owe at the end of the tenancy?
HousingThe agent offered us a choice between a refundable tenancy deposit and a deposit-replacement product. My flatmate called the smaller initial payment a saving. The product summary describes a non-refundable joining fee and an annual charge, but we have not worked through what happens if the landlord makes a claim.
We are applying for a private rental in England. The traditional deposit would tie up more of our savings during the tenancy; the alternative would leave us more cash for moving. I can see the attraction without being sure we are comparing the same kind of payment.
[The government's tenant-fees guidance says tenants may choose a deposit-replacement product, but cannot be required to buy a loan, insurance or service contract as a condition of the tenancy](https://www.gov.uk/guidance/tenant-fees-act-2019-guidance-for-tenants).
What should we have explained before choosing? I want to understand the ongoing fees and any remaining liability, rather than assume that paying less at move-in means the whole arrangement costs less.