Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

The credit union requires a $5 membership share. Should I record it as an opening fee?

Money category photographMoney

The account terms in this example require a $5 membership share to stay on deposit. The opening statement shows $5 in a share savings account, but I recorded it as a joining expense because I couldn't spend it from checking.

The NCUA's consumer glossary explains that a credit-union member is an owner and calls the savings account a regular share account.

How would you distinguish money kept in that account from a separate nonrefundable charge? I also want to ask what happens to the balance if I close the membership, rather than assume it is either freely available today or gone for good.

Discussion

5 community replies

Check the account agreement and fee schedule separately. A statement balance is evidence of money in the account; an opening fee would be a charge to identify on its own.

For your own budget, you could track the $5 as money held in the share account but unavailable for routine spending. That preserves the balance without pretending it can fund this week's groceries.

Ask the credit union to explain its required balance, withdrawal conditions and membership-closure process. The $5 in this example isn't a universal amount for every institution.

If I can't withdraw the $5 while remaining a member, doesn't that make it a fee in practice?

It can have a cost in terms of access to your money, which matters when comparing accounts. But limited access doesn't itself show that the balance was spent as a fee. Confirm what the agreement says about the funds, including what happens on closure.

Join the discussion

More in Money