Real people. Real opinions.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

The consultation form offers two options I can't support. What should I write?

Politics category photographPolitics

"Just tick the less bad one," my neighbour said when I showed her the consultation form. I understand why: she had spent half an hour on it and wanted her objection counted.

In this fictional UK government consultation, a department proposes concentrating publicly funded evening training courses at a larger centre. The form asks whether sessions should start at six or seven. My difficulty is that the course I take finishes after the last connection home from either start time. There is a box for additional comments, but no question about a local session or a different finishing time.

I don't know whether the department has already settled the location or whether that is still open. The introduction says responses will help develop the scheme, which sounds promising without telling me which decisions could change.

If I pick six, my answer might look like support for an option I couldn't use. If I refuse to pick either, I'm worried the practical problem will be buried in an extra-comments box. My neighbour wants us to submit identical objections so the issue is obvious; my circumstances aren't exactly the same as hers.

How would you answer the form honestly and make the unresolved decision clear, without pretending to know what the department is obliged to do?

The consultation, course and travel arrangements are fictional.

Discussion

2 community replies

Use the additional-comments box to separate your position from the offered choice: "Neither start time resolves my journey home. Please explain whether location and finishing time remain open." The [Cabinet Office's consultation principles](https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/consultation-principles-guidance/consultation-principles-2018) say government departments should consult while plans are still developing and explain how responses informed policy. That guidance does not itself have legal force or promise that your preferred option will be adopted.

Describe the connection you would miss and what adjustment would make attendance possible. Keep it to your actual circumstances in this scenario; you don't need to claim that everyone has the same journey. A clear practical obstacle gives the department something specific to examine even if it doesn't accept your proposed solution.

Join the discussion

More in Politics