Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

The cheaper insurance quote has the same contents limit. Does 'actual cash value' change the comparison?

Money category photographMoney

The two home-insurance quotes show the same contents limit and deductible, but one costs $38 less a year. I nearly chose it before noticing that its contents cover says actual cash value. The other says replacement cost.

These are example quotes, not market prices. I haven't compared the other policy terms or asked for a sample explanation of a covered loss.

The NAIC explains that actual cash value takes age and wear into account, while replacement-cost cover concerns repair or replacement with like kind and quality, subject to the policy.

I can afford either premium. What would you ask so the comparison includes what we'd have to find after a loss, rather than treating an equal limit as evidence of equal cover?

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask the insurer to walk through the same covered example under both quotes, showing depreciation, deductible and any limits. An illustration from the actual policy terms is more useful than guessing what every old item would be worth.

Check how replacement-cost payments are made and what documents or replacement steps the policy requires. The label alone doesn't explain the entire claim process.

Consider what you could afford to contribute after a loss. The annual $38 saving is definite in your quotes; the possible difference in a claim needs understanding before you decide how much uncertainty to accept.

If most of your belongings are old and inexpensive, couldn't the cheaper version still fit?

It could, depending on what replacing necessary items would cost you and what the rest of the policy covers. Review that actual need instead of assuming either that old belongings have no value or that replacement-cost cover is automatically the right choice.

Join the discussion

More in Money