Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

The cheaper car lease allows fewer miles than I currently drive. What should go into the comparison?

Money category photographMoney

The advertised US lease allows 10,000 miles a year for three years. I currently drive about 12,000, but a possible job change could reduce that. My partner wants to compare the smaller monthly payment with a higher-mileage quote.

At an illustrative 25 cents per excess mile, keeping my current driving pattern would mean 6,000 extra miles over three years and $1,500 in mileage charges, assuming those are the contract's terms. That calculation excludes other costs. We haven't signed.

The FTC advises checking mileage limits and end-of-lease charges.

How would you compare the two written offers without treating the possible shorter commute as certain, or paying for a larger allowance without checking what it buys?

Discussion

5 community replies

Use the same term, upfront costs and other assumptions when comparing quotes. Put the full mileage allowance and excess-mile rate beside each monthly payment.

Check the proposed contract's actual mileage calculation. The $1,500 example follows the stated assumptions; it isn't a quote for every lease or every change in mileage.

Keep wear, damage and other return charges separate from excess mileage. Buying a larger mileage allowance wouldn't by itself establish that every end-of-lease charge is covered.

If the new job cuts driving to 8,000 miles a year, wouldn't the lower allowance be enough?

Under that scenario it could be. Compare it with the current 12,000-mile pattern and any other realistic case, then check how the agreement handles changes or unused mileage. A possible job move should remain a scenario until it is confirmed.

Join the discussion

More in Money