Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

Six of us want to play a five-player board game. Is pairing two people a fair solution?

Gaming category photographGaming

We were choosing a game for six people when the host brought out one with five player positions. They suggested that the two least experienced players share a position and make decisions together. One liked the idea; the other said they wanted to learn by making their own choices.

The host had prepared this game and didn't want another long explanation of something else. I can see why sharing looked like a quick solution. It only works as an invitation, though, if both people actually want the shared role.

What should we consider before settling on it? I don't want the newest players to become the automatic pair whenever the table doesn't quite fit.

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask both people whether they want to share, separately from whether they think it would help the host. One person's enthusiasm doesn't answer for the other.

Check whether this game would let both people participate meaningfully in a shared position. Sitting beside the person making every decision may not offer the learning experience the second player wants.

Another game is still an option even though this one was prepared. Acknowledge the host's work while comparing it with the evening six people can actually enjoy.

If the group does try a shared position, agree how the two players will make choices rather than leave the more confident person as the permanent captain.

And let either person say that the arrangement isn't working. A trial should provide information about the format, not become a promise to enjoy it until everyone else has finished.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming