Should we replace borrowed holiday binoculars with a new pair after losing them?
TravelLeo returns from the coach excursion with the case for Priya's binoculars, but no binoculars. He remembers leaving them on a bench. The tour company has checked and has not found them.
Priya lent him a pair she had owned for years. They were working well, and she had planned to use them for the rest of their birdwatching holiday. Leo apologises and offers to find a comparable second-hand pair when they get home.
Priya would rather have a new replacement. The exact model is no longer sold new, and the alternative she has found costs more than Leo expected. He says he should replace what he lost, not fund an upgrade. She says she did not ask to spend the holiday without her equipment and then search used listings.
They had not agreed what would happen if something was lost. How should they work out a replacement that takes the working pair's value and Priya's lost use seriously, without treating either the original purchase price or the newest model as the automatic answer?